Decoding comparable morphologies: Pigmentation validated for identifying southern California Paralabrax larvae

Erica Teresa Jarvis MASON, Lucille BULKELEY, William W. WATSON, Allyson C. Salazar SAWKINS, Matthew T. CRAIG, John R. HYDE, Andrew R. THOMPSON, Brice X. SEMMENS


The distribution and trends in larval fish abundance are often used to assess the status and trends of marine fish populations. However, for closely related species whose larvae are morphologically similar and whose genetic identities may be degraded by formalin preservation, unraveling species-specific larval abundances from long-term monitoring efforts presents a challenge. We used statistical methods and the molecular identities of 107 ethanol-preserved specimens to construct and test a taxonomic key based on pigmentation patterns observed in three species of Paralabrax (family Serranidae) from southern California. Previously, larvae of these species were not thought to be reliably distinguishable based on morphology or pigmentation.  However, when using pigmentation characters paired with molecular identities, a Random Forest Classifier provided a tool for structuring and refining a taxonomic key to distinguish species. Following calibration and key refinement, the probabilities of achieving accurate and precise species classifications using our taxonomic key were >96%, indicating that ventral and pectoral fin pigmentation patterns can discriminate Paralabrax larvae. Importantly, we can now leverage existing and future ichthyoplankton survey collections to assess species-specific trends in larval abundance without requiring expensive and lab-intensive genetic analyses used with formalin-fixed specimens.



Larvae, Pigmentation, Key, Random forest, Molecular validation.

Full Text:



Allen L.G., Block H.E. 2012. Planktonic larval duration, settlement, and growth rates of the young-of-the-year of two sand basses (Paralabrax nebulifer and P. maculatofasciatus: Fam. Serranidae) from Southern California. Southern California Academy of Sciences Bulletin 111: 15-21.

Avendaño-Ibarra R. 2004. Cambios en la abundancia larval del genero Paralabrax (Pisces: Serranidae) en Bahía Magdalena, durante 1982-1986. M.Sc. thesis, Departamento de Plancton y Ecología Marina, Instituto Politécnico Nacional Centro Interdisciplinario de Ciencias Marinas. 112 p.

Avendaño-Ibarra R., Aceves-Medina G., Godínez-Domínguez E., De Silva-Dávila R., Jiménez-Rosenberg S.P.A., Urias-Leyva H., Robinson C.J. 2014. Fish larvae from the Gulf of California to Colima, Mexico: An update. Check List 10: 106-121.

Avendaño-Ibarra R., Funes-Rodríguez R., Hinojosa-Medina A., González-Armas R., Aceves-Medina G. 2004. Seasonal abundance of fish larvae in a subtropical lagoon in the west coast of the Baja California Peninsula. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science 61: 125-135.

Butler J.L., Moser H.G., Hageman G.S., Nordgren L.E. 1982. Developmental stages of three California sea basses. California Cooperative Fisheries Investigations Reports 23: 252-268.

Cota-Nieto J.J., Erisman B., Aburto-Oropeza O., Moreno-Báez M., Hinojosa-Arango G., Johnson A.F. 2018. Participatory management in a small-scale coastal fishery-Punta Abreojos, Pacific coast of Baja California Sur, Mexico. Regional Studies in Marine Science 18: 68-79.

Cutler D.R., Edwards T.C., Beard K.H., Cutler A., Hess K.T., Gibson J., Lawler J.J. 2007. Random forests for classification in ecology. Ecology 88: 2783-2792.

Erisman B.E., Allen L.G. 2005. Color Patterns and Associated Behaviors in the Kelp Bass, Paralabrax clathratus (Teleostei: Serranidae). Bulletin, Southern California Academy of Sciences 104: 45-62.

Erisman B.E., Allen L.G., Claisse J.T., Pondella II D.J., Miller E.F., Murray J.H., Walters C. 2011. The illusion of plenty: hyperstability masks collapses in two recreational fisheries that target fish spawning aggregations. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 68: 1705-1716.

Erisman B.E., Cota-Nieto J.J., Moreno-Báez M., Aburto-Oropeza O. 2017. Vulnerability of spawning aggregations of a coastal marine fish to a small-scale fishery. Marine Biology 164:1–18.

Findlay A.M., Allen L.G. 2002. Temporal patterns of settlement in the temperate reef fish Paralabrax clathratus. Marine Ecology Progress Series 238: 237-248.

Gallo N.D., Drenkard E., Thompson A.R., Weber E.D., Wilson-Vandenberg D., Mcclatchie S., Koslow, J.A., Semmens B.X. 2019. Bridging from monitoring to solutions-based thinking: lessons from CalCOFI for understanding and adapting to marine climate change impacts. Frontiers in Marine Science 6: 1-21.

Gaxiola-Castrol G., Najera-Martinez S. 2002. The Mexican oceanographic North Pacific program: IMECOCAL. In: H.P. Batchelder, G.A. McFarlane, B.A. Megrey, D.L. Mackas, W.T. Peterson (Eds.). PICES Scientific Report No. 20. PICES-GLOBEC international program on climate change and carrying capacity. North Pacific Marine Science Organization (PICES). Sidney, B.C., Canada. pp. 14-16.

Gray A.K., Kendall A.W., Wing B.L., Carls M.G., Heifetz J., Li Z., Gharrett A.J. 2006. Identification and first documentation of larval rockfishes in southeast Alaskan waters was possible using mitochondrial markers but not pigmentation patterns. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society 135: 1-11.

Heemstra P.C. 1995. Serranidae. Meros, serranos, guasetas, enjambres, baquetas, indios, loros, gallinas, cabrillas, garropas. In: W. Fischer, F. Krupp, W. Schneider, C. Sommer, K.E. Carpenter, V. Niem (Eds.). Guia FAO para identification de especies para lo fines de la pesca. Pacifico Centro-Oriental. Volume II. FAO, Rome, Italy. pp: 1565-1613.

Hyde J.R., Lynn E., Humphreys R., Musyl M., West A.P., Vetter R. 2005. Shipboard identification of fish eggs and larvae by multiplex PCR, and description of fertilized eggs of blue marlin, shortbill spearfish, and wahoo. Marine Ecology Progress Series 286: 269-277.

Jarvis E.T., Gliniak H.L., Valle C.F. 2014a. Effects of fishing and the environment on the long-term sustainability of the recreational saltwater bass fishery in southern California. California Fish and Game 100: 234-259.

Jarvis E.T., Loke-Smith K.A., Evans K., Kloppe R.E., Young K.A., Valle C.F. 2014b. Reproductive potential and spawning periodicity in barred sand bass (Paralabrax nebulifer) from the San Pedro Shelf, southern California. California Fish and Game 100: 289-309.

Jiao Y., Du P. 2016. Performance measures in evaluating machine learning based bioinformatics predictors for classifications. Quantitative Biology 4: 320-330.

Kuhn M. 2022. Package “caret”: Classification and Regression Training. R package version 6.0-91. Available from:

Liaw A., Wiener M. 2002a. Classification and regression by randomforest. R News 2: 18-22.

Liaw A., Wiener M. 2022b. Package “randomforest.” Available from: /randomforest/index.html.

Love M.S., Passerelli J.K. 2020. Miller and Lea’s guide to the coastal marine fishes of California, 2nd edition. University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources 202. 419 p.

McClatchie S. 2014. Regional fisheries oceanography of the California current system. The CalCOFI program. Springer. 235 p.

McElreath, R. 2019. Statistical Rethinking 2nd Edition. CRC Press. 601 p.

McKinzie M.K., Jarvis E.T., Lowe C.G. 2014. Fine-scale horizontal and vertical movement of barred sand bass, Paralabrax nebulifer, during spawning and non-spawning seasons. Fisheries Research 150: 66-75.

Miller B., Kendall A.W. 2009. Early life history of marine fishes. Berkeley: University of California Press. 376 p.

Miller E.F., Erisman B. 2014. Long-term trends of southern California’s kelp and barred sand bass populations: A fishery-independent assessment. California Cooperative Oceanic Fisheries Investigations Reports 55: 1-9.

Moser H.G., Charter R.L., Watson W., Ambrose D.A., Hill K.T., Smith P.E., Butler J.L., Sandknop E.M., Charter S.R. 2001. The CalCOFI ichthyoplankton time series: Potential contributions to the management of rocky-shore fishes. California Cooperative Oceanic Fisheries Investigations Reports 42: 112-128.

Plummer M. 2021. Package ‘rjags’. Available from:

R-Core-Team. 2020. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Available from:

Schnell N.K., Konstantinidis P., Johnson G.D. 2016. High-proof ethanol fixation of larval and juvenile fishes for clearing and double staining. Copeia 104: 617-622.

Su Y-S., Yajima M. 2021. Package “r2jags” (Version:0.5-7). Available from:

Taylor C.A., Watson W. 2004. Utility of larval pigmentation to identify nearshore rockfishes of the Sebastes subgenus Pteropodus from southern California. California Cooperative Oceanic Fisheries Investigations Reports 45: 113-117.

Tharwat, A. 2018. Classification assessment methods. Applied Computing and Informatics 17: 168-192.

Thompson A.R., Chen D.C., Guo L.W., Hyde J.R., Watson W. 2017. Larval abundances of rockfishes that were historically targeted by fishing increased over 16 years in association with a large marine protected area. Royal Society Open Science 4:170639.

Thompson A.R., Hyde J.R., Watson W., Chen D.C., Guo L.W. 2016. Rockfish assemblage structure and spawning locations in southern California identified through larval sampling. Marine Ecology Progress Series 547:177-192.

Wang Y-T., Tzeng W-N. 1997. A quick method to identify Engraulid fish larvae in the Tanshui River estuary in Northern Taiwan. Acta Zoologica Taiwanica 8: 23-32.

Watson W. 1998. Serranidae: Sea basses. In: H.G. Moser (Ed.). The early stages of fishes in the California current region. California Cooperative Fisheries Investigations Atlas No. 33. 1508 p.

Watson W., Charter S.R., Lawley C.A.T. 2016. Early larvae of the swordspine rockfish (Sebastes ensifer) identified by molecular methods. Fishery Bulletin 114: 135-143.

Watson, W., Davis R.L. 1989. Larval fish diets in shallow coastal waters off San Onofre, California. Fishery Bulletin 87: 569-591.

Watson W., Robertson L.L. 2004. Development of kelp rockfish, Sebastes atrovirens (Jordan and Gilbert 1880), and brown rockfish, S. auriculatus (Girard 1854), from birth to pelagic juvenile stage, with notes on early larval development of black-and-yellow rockfish, S. chrysomelas (Jordan and Gilbert 1880), reared in the laboratory (Pisces: Sebastidae). NOAA Professional Papers NMFS 3. 30 p.


  • There are currently no refbacks.